What criteria must a surgeon meet for a player to choose them?

For a player to choose a surgeon, the surgeon must be board certified. This certification is crucial as it indicates that the surgeon has completed extensive training and has demonstrated proficiency in their specialty. Board certification assures the player that the surgeon adheres to high standards of competence, ethics, and professionalism, which is especially important when dealing with medical decisions that can significantly impact a player's career and physical well-being.

While being a team doctor might provide familiarity with the player's medical history and the team's specific needs, it is not a requirement for the player to select them. Prior NFL experience may be beneficial for understanding the unique demands of football injuries, but it does not equate to the necessary qualifications for surgical practice. Lastly, having the surgeon located in the same city is not a criterion that directly relates to the quality or certification of the surgeon. Board certification remains the key standard for ensuring that a surgeon is suitably qualified to perform necessary medical procedures for NFL players.